The Varukers All articles
Opinion

The Critics Weren't Wrong, They Were Just Rude About It

The Varukers
The Critics Weren't Wrong, They Were Just Rude About It

Photo: Graham Hogg , CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Dig through enough clippings about this band and a pattern emerges. The bad reviews weren't inaccurate. They were written by people who thought accuracy was an insult.

That's the uncomfortable thing about defending a band like The Varukers against the press. You go looking for the unfair ones — the lazy sneers, the ninety-word write-ups by a man who clearly wished he was reviewing something with a saxophone on it. And you find them. But you also find that a lot of the hostility was, technically, bang on the money. The band were loud. The production was thin on purpose. The songs did not have bridges. Nobody was ever going to be moved to tears by the chord changes.

So perhaps the interesting question isn't whether the critics were wrong. It's what they were telling us without meaning to.

What 'unlistenable' was actually confessing

Call a record unlistenable and you have told the reader precisely nothing about the record — you've told them everything about your threshold. It's a word that measures the reviewer, not the noise. When a weekly music paper's man used it about a hardcore record in the early eighties, what he was really reporting was that his reference points had run out. The vocabulary he'd built for guitar music didn't stretch far enough to describe a band playing at that speed with that little interest in being liked.

That's not a review. That's a shrug in a leather jacket. And a shrug can be quite informative, because it marks the edge of the map. Everything past that edge was the actual interesting stuff.

Derivative is what a shared language looks like

The other reliable word in the cuttings is derivative. Every punk band of that era got it, and it's a criticism that only works if you've decided punk is supposed to be an individual artistic statement rather than a shared vernacular.

Because yes — the riffs came out of the same handful of records everyone else was listening to. Yes, the drumming owed a debt. That's what a scene is. A language doesn't get less useful because other people are speaking it. The snobbery baked into derivative assumes originality is the highest virtue, which is a very comfortable position to hold from a desk in London, and a completely useless one if you're trying to describe why four hundred people in a room in the Midlands all lost their minds at the same moment.

The class tell in a two-star write-up

Read enough of these and you notice the tone does something specific. It's not the tone of someone who disliked the music. It's the tone of someone who disliked being in the room — a faint, unmistakable distaste for the venue, the crowd, the accents, the whole apparatus of people making culture without asking permission.

You can hear it in the words chosen for the audience: shambolic, amateurish, charmless. None of those words are about sound. They're about class. They're the vocabulary of a gatekeeper realising the gate is no longer doing anything, because the band has already walked through it and taken the crowd with them.

And that's the part the sneer couldn't say out loud: the band didn't need the review. A bad notice in a national paper didn't empty a room. The flyers did more for the cause than the colour supplements ever managed.

Politeness is the real insult

Compare that to how music gets covered now. Nearly everything gets three and a half stars and a paragraph of neutral adjectives. There is no risk in it, no stakes, no argument. It's coverage as admin — a listing with opinions attached so mild they evaporate on contact.

I'd take the sneer. Genuinely. A hostile review from 1983 that mentions the smell of the room and the speed of the set and the fact that the singer looked like he meant it is a more honest document than a modern five-hundred-word write-up that could have been generated from a press release without anyone listening to a note.

Hostility is engagement. It means someone was in the room and it did something to them. Politeness means nobody was home.

The compliment buried in all of it

So no, the critics weren't wrong. They were rude, condescending, and frequently accurate about the surface facts — loud, fast, repetitive, unreconstructed, allergic to subtlety. Every one of those is a description of the thing working exactly as designed.

The real failure would have been a mature album. A bridging record. A thoughtful reinvention for the grown-ups. Nobody reviewing this band ever demanded that, because they understood — even the ones who hated it — that there was nothing to mature into. What you saw was what it was, and it was never going to ask for your approval.

The press gave this band honesty, in the end, even if it came wrapped in condescension. That's more than most get.

All Articles

Related Articles

Earplugs, Bus Fares and Standing Your Ground: A First-Timer's Guide to a Varukers Show

Earplugs, Bus Fares and Standing Your Ground: A First-Timer's Guide to a Varukers Show

Laughing in the Face of the Apocalypse: The Varukers' Deadly Gift for Dark Comedy

Laughing in the Face of the Apocalypse: The Varukers' Deadly Gift for Dark Comedy

Your Shout, Their Stage: The Messy, Brilliant Reality of Fan-Driven Setlists

Your Shout, Their Stage: The Messy, Brilliant Reality of Fan-Driven Setlists